last updated: December 2023
© 2023, NiPERA Inc.
A small portion of the nickel allergic population are susceptible to allergic reactions from oral exposure to nickel substances, most commonly through food and beverages. These individuals may benefit from a low nickel diet, which should only be undertaken when advised by a dermatologist or other qualified medical doctor.
This fact sheet discusses some of the existing low nickel diets made available by clinics, dermatologists, medical doctors, and on the internet. This fact sheet also briefly explains the origins of nickel in food and examines some of the other potential sources of nickel. In particular, sources that are sometimes highlighted by dermatologists and medical doctors but for which data does not conclusively support substantial contribution to nickel intake (e.g., bottled water versus tap water, canned foods, and the use of stainless steel cookware) are addressed. Recommendations are made with regard to these sources.
Annex I to this fact sheet provides an extensive, non-exhaustive list of foodstuffs that are categorized as high, medium, and low in nickel and expressed in terms of micrograms per kilogram (µg/kg) of food. In order to assist users with compliance with a low nickel diet, each foodstuff within the relevant category is also listed with its nickel content in terms of micrograms per serving (µg/serving).
last updated: December 2023
© 2023, NiPERA Inc.
This is the sixth in a series of fact sheets addressing issues specific to the evaluation of risks to humans associated with nickel-containing substances and materials. The fact sheets are intended to assist the reader in understanding the complex issues and concepts associated with assessment of human health hazards, dose-response relationships, and exposure by summarizing key technical information and providing guidance for implementation.
This material has been prepared for the general information of the reader and it is not intended to be medical or technical advice for specific situations. The publication is based on current scientific knowledge and while believed to be technically correct, it should not be used or relied upon in specific cases without first securing professional advice. Nickel Institute, its members, staff, and consultants do not represent or warrant its suitability for any general or specific use and assume no liability or responsibility of any kind in connection with the information herein.
NiPERA welcomes questions about anything stated in this fact sheet. For inquiries, please contact Katherine Heim, Ph.D., DABT at kheim@nipera.org.
This fact sheet was prepared by Mr. Tony Newson,
Consultant, tonyn1950@yahoo.com.
Nickel metal and its compounds, as well as some nickel-containing alloys, are skin sensitizers. These materials can sensitize (i.e., make allergic) people to nickel or elicit a dermal allergic reaction in nickel-sensitized individuals when in close and prolonged contact with the skin if a sufficient amount of nickel ions is released (above the threshold for a nickel allergic reaction). A study conducted by the Danish Environmental Protection Agency on nickel allergy has shown prevalence, in the general population, to be between 8 – 18% depending on the European country.(1) Alinaghi et al. (2019)(2) reviewed numerous studies of prevalence of allergens in the general population over may years and around the world, estimating nickel allergy to be 11.4%. The percentage of females sensitized to nickel is higher than the figure for males.
Important considerations regarding nickel allergy are listed below.
Numerous versions of low nickel diets exist, which are provided by dermatologists and other doctors directly to patients or are published on the internet.(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19) While many of the same food items are included in these lists, not all of the recommendations and background information provided on SNAS are consistent or correct (e.g., foods cooked in stainless steel pans, canned goods). Hence, it is possible that the users of such diets may not receive the anticipated reduction of their nickel dermatitis outbreaks and/or that the recommendations result only in unnecessary and costly changes in habits and purchases that could affect their health in other ways. Furthermore, following a low nickel diet may lead to the unwarranted avoidance of nickel-containing food contact materials that are common, economical, and already regulated (under separate legislation) to ensure their safe use, even if they contain nickel.
Penn State Hershey Medical Center recommends that after following their diet for one to three months without any improvement the diet should be discontinued.(10) Similarly, Drs. M. Mislankar and M. J. Zirwas indicate that it may take up to two months to reap the benefits from following their low nickel diet.(12) Rebelytics Research and Development Inc. warns that their diet is intended for individuals diagnosed with systemic nickel allergy and that the diet must not be entered into lightly.(14)
With the publication of the European Food Safety Agency’s (EFSA) recent update of its Scientific Opinion on Nickel in Food and Drinking Water,(20)(21) there is a renewed interest on the topic of nickel in the diet and in drinking water and an opportunity to better inform the general public, regulators, and other stakeholders. Although the numbers of those affected by SNAS is low, these individuals need access to accurate and reliable information as there is the potential for and evidence of unwarranted health concerns being raised about the oral intake of nickel in food and beverages.
Nickel occurs extensively in the earth's crust and core.(22) Nickel in adequate quantities has a vital role in a wide range of physiological processes.(23) It is an essential trace element for all plants and microbes, as well as certain animal species.(22)(24) Nickel deficiency in these animals has been noted to have an adverse effect on the concentration of other essential metals including iron, copper, and zinc.(24) As its presence in soil varies, it is not surprising that the level of nickel in foods also varies in different plant species with the nickel content of the soil and with the seasons. In addition, different species require and use different amounts of nickel, resulting in some foods having higher nickel content than others.(22)(24) Animals absorb nickel from food, water, and their environment (especially aquatic species). As most foods contain some measurable level of nickel, an entirely nickel-free diet is not possible.
As nickel is usually measured in food as total nickel and there is limited information on the different chemical species of nickel in food, this fact sheet refers to “nickel” in all its forms in food. Limited information is available on the content or dietary intake of different chemical species of nickel in food. Generally, it is assumed that nickel occurs as complex bound organic nickel molecules in the divalent state (Ni II) with different physico-chemical properties than inorganic nickel(25) and has been demonstrated for some beverages and plants.(26)(27)(28)(29)
While data from numerous studies on nickel in food can disagree markedly on their recommendations for items with low nickel levels, most studies indicate that the sources of highest potential dietary nickel are found in nuts, dried peas and beans, whole grains, and chocolate. Annex I provides a non-exhaustive list of nickel-containing foodstuffs extracted from the updated EFSA Scientific Opinion on nickel in food and drinking water,(20) the INNIBEL report on nickel in foodstuffs on the Belgian market,(30) and the global listing from the Rebelytics Low-Nickel Global Diet Scoring System.(14) Annex I categorizes foodstuffs as high (more than 500 µg/kg), medium (100 – 500 µg/kg), and low (less than 100 µg/kg) in nickel. The information is presented in terms of the average and typical ranges of nickel content per serving. Serving sizes are based on the Rebelytics global listing,(14) which uses Health Canada's serving sizes(31) to generate its micrograms of nickel per serving data. This approach is taken because the nickel content of foodstuffs is usually reported in milligrams of nickel per kilogram of food (mg/kg), which is not easily related to micrograms per serving (µg/serving) as more useful numbers for people following a low nickel diet. This is especially true for diets that aim to limit nickel intake to 150 micrograms per day or 15 points per day (according to the point systems discussed in more detail below).
Low nickel diets tend to fall into two distinct categories. One type is based on categorization of high, medium, and low nickel-containing foods, drinks, and beverages, where avoidance of high nickel-containing foods is recommended, and low nickel-containing foods are permitted.(10)(11) Some diets also permit medium nickel-containing foods that are managed by limiting their intake.(11) Such information is usually provided in the form of lists,(10) which may also be accompanied by an indication of the nickel content of each food or by recommendations regarding the quantity and frequency of consumption. For example, bananas (in moderation), apples (up to 3 – 4 times a week), and citrus fruits (up to 3 – 4 times a week) may be permitted.(11) However, this approach to reducing nickel in the diet can be quite challenging due to adherence difficulties and management of the overall nickel intake(13) (e.g., where those following low nickel diet can find it difficult to relate the nickel content of foods to the amount of nickel contained per serving as noted above).
Another approach is that originally designed by Drs. M. Mislankar and M. J. Zirwas(12) which uses a simple "Low-Nickel Diet Scoring System" where the overall objective is a low-nickel diet that does not exceed 150 μg of nickel per day or equivalent to 15 “points” per day. The serving sizes are based on the US Food and Drug Administration (US FDA) approved serving sizes.1 Thus, the authors arrived at a system of micrograms (µg) nickel per serving (e.g., yogurt 5.34 µg Ni/175 g). Table 1 is based on the publication by Mislankar and Zirwas(12) in which each food listed was assigned a score from 0 to 10.
Table 1: Overview of scoring system
for Mislankar and Zirwas approach
Score | Micrograms (µg) Nickel Per Serving |
0 | For foods with less than 1 µg/serving |
1 | For foods with 1 to 10 µg/serving |
2 | For foods with 11 to 20 µg/serving |
and on up to | |
10 | For foods with 91 to 100 µg/serving |
In the Mislankar and Zirwas Low-Nickel Diet Scoring System,(12) foods with more than 100 µg nickel per serving are to be avoided entirely. For children under the age of 12 years, no more than 10 points per day should be consumed. In very rare cases, individuals that are particularly sensitive to nickel may need to limit their intake to 5 points per day if directed by their doctor.
One example of an adaptation to Mislankar and Zirwas approach is the low nickel diet system provided by Rebelytics,(14) which is based on nickel content data from multiple sources (including data from national health organizations and research papers) to compute a weighted average that reflects the potential local variations in food sources, manufacturing, and food preparation methods. Rebelytics used Health Canada’s serving sizes(31) to generate its micrograms of nickel per serving data. As with the Mislankar and Zirwas scoring system, Rebelytics assigned points to their food lists and the objective is to limit nickel intake to 15 points per day. Unlike the Mislankar and Zirwas approach, Rebelytics provides global and regional lists of nickel values on their website.(14) Other low nickel diet plans are also available online, each prescribing their own schedule.(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)
While the food values in all of these diets are helpful, it should be noted that the recommendations regarding use of stainless steel cookware and utensils, as well as consumption of canned foods and drinking water, may not be accurate. These topics are specifically addressed later in this fact sheet.
1 While based on the US Food and Drug Administration (US FDA) approved serving sizes in 2012, the Mislankar and Zirwas(12) low nickel diet scoring system used double the standard serving sizes because Americans frequently consume larger portions. The US FDA updated their serving sizes in 2016 (last amended in 2022)(32) to reflect increased consumption, though the values are still lower than twice the previous values used by Mislankar and Zirwas(12) in 2013 for their low nickel diet.
In order to facilitate comparison, the data on selected dairy products in Table 2 is presented in terms of micrograms of nickel per serving. The EFSA(20) and INNIBEL(30) data is presented using the Rebelytics serving portions (from Health Canada),(14) while Mislankar and Zirwas data is presented in terms of the serving portions derived by the US Food and Drug Administration (multiplied by 2).(12) The factors influencing the variation in nickel content of foodstuffs are as follows:
Thus, the quantity of nickel found in animals and plants will vary according to both the level of nickel compounds in soil in their locality and the amount of uptake.
The range of nickel content of foodstuffs shown by dairy products in Table 2 illustrates these influences. The larger the number of samples of food from different areas of the globe, the greater the range of nickel contents that are likely to be reported, with the Rebelytics Global diet having the highest range.
Therefore, regional information on nickel content is relevant when considering a low nickel diet, if available. For example, the Rebelytics diet(14) provides regional dietary information (as well as global).
Nickel-containing stainless steels are one of the most widely used food contact materials; applications range from domestic utensils and kitchen equipment, through commercial catering equipment to mass food production equipment. Stainless steels are selected for these applications because of their cleanability, durability, hygienic properties, inertness, and their excellent mechanical/physical properties such as corrosion resistance which result in very low, if any, nickel release.
In these food contact applications, stainless steels fulfill the key regulatory requirements that constituents are not transferred to food in quantities sufficient to bring about unacceptable changes in its composition, color, odor, taste, or texture.(33) They satisfy, too, the explicit requirement that substances in food contact materials and articles (FCM&As) should not be released in quantities that endanger human health. Studies(34)(35) have shown that stainless steels used in FCM&As release low amounts of nickel and other alloying ingredients that are within regulatory limits or guidelines. The European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines & Healthcare (EDQM) Technical Guide on Metals and Alloys Used in Food Contact Materials and Articles(36) includes an appropriate protocol for metal release testing. Provided that the manufacturers’ recommendations for care and cleaning are followed, even scratched and scoured stainless steel saucepans should not present a problem for individuals suffering from SNAS.
Several studies have demonstrated low nickel release from stainless steels used in food contact materials.(34)(36)(37) Nickel release from nickel-containing stainless steel grades tested in food simulants decreased with each successive use.(35)(37)
Higher nickel release values were reported for stainless steels by other researchers.(38)(39)(40) However, two of these studies used test methods that were not in accordance with accepted national or international protocols,(38)(39) with one study testing non-relevant stainless steel granules using excessive cooking times.(39)
Many low nickel diets, irrespective of whether they originate from dermatologists, clinics, or online articles/blogs, advise individuals displaying symptoms of SNAS to avoid eating canned food altogether or, at the very least, to eat it only in moderation. The explanation most often given is that some cans are made with materials (alloys) that contain nickel and nickel can dissociate from the alloy of the can and thus increases the total nickel content of the canned food.(8)
Food cans are made of three different materials: aluminium (does not contain nickel), electrolytic tinplate steel (ETP, contains 0.08% maximum nickel), and electrolytic chromium coated steel (ECCS, contains 0.08% maximum nickel). In addition, food cans are typically coated with an additional organic layer that protects the integrity of the can from effects of the food and prevents chemical reactions between the metal coating of the can and the food.(41) The type of can selected for food applications depends on the food type (e.g., aluminium cans are not used for highly acidic fruits). In a limited number of applications, unlacquered ETP cans are used (e.g., tomato-based products)(42) and, in these sealed cans, the presence of a bare tin surface inside the can leads to protection of the natural flavor and appearance of the food.(42)
In a study of the level of metals in fresh and canned foods (typically packaged in coated steel or aluminum cans) consumed in North Central Nigeria,(43) Dallatu et al. found that there was no significant difference in the levels of nickel and other metals in fresh and canned foods. In addition, the nickel concentrations were below the specific release limit for nickel recommended by the EDQM Technical Guide on Metals and Alloys Used in Food Contact Materials and Articles.(36)
This lack of contribution of nickel in canned foods to the diet is supported by comparing the values of nickel in foodstuffs reported the Rebelytics Low Nickel Diet Scoring System(14) and the results reported by Noureddine El Moussawi et al.(44) for fresh and canned fava beans, chickpeas, and okra. The nickel release patterns may be linked to the low nickel composition (less than 0.8% weight3)(41) in the steel alloy used to construct the cans, resulting in a slow release over time.(45)
A number of other published studies have measured nickel content in canned foods, but without a comparison to nickel content in foods prior to canning, storage time, and conditions of storage.(46)(47)(48)(49)(50)(51)(52)(53)(54)(55)(56)(57)(58)(59)(60)(61) While these studies demonstrate, generally, greater nickel contents in canned food, it is not possible to determine whether the additional nickel content of canned foods occurs because of natural variations in soil, from the canning materials, the canning process, or the storage time and storage conditions.
Nickel and other metal ions can accumulate in tap water supply systems such as taps/faucets during times of stagnation (i.e., when the faucet/tap is unused overnight or during holiday periods). Hence, some diets that list high, medium, and low nickel-containing foods, drinks, and beverages advise that water taken from the tap (faucet) after periods of stagnation should be discarded and should not be used in food preparation.(10)(11)(13)
The Rebelytics Global Low Nickel Diet Scoring System(14) provides a score of 1 per serving for both bottled water average <10 µg/serving (375 g) [range 0 – 190 µg/serving (375 g)] and tap water average <10 µg/serving (375 g) [range 0 – 20 µg/ serving (375 g)]. Similar data reported by EFSA(20) for bottled and tap water, shown in Annex I , indicates the same range of nickel values apply to both sources of water. According to the EFSA data, bottled water has a mean nickel ion content of 2.6 µg/serving (375 g) compared with 0.4 µg/serving (375 g) for tap water.
It is important to emphasize that a low nickel diet should only be followed by individuals who are susceptible to SNAS, and only when advised by a dermatologist or their medical doctor. Regional information for nickel levels should be considered when available.
Low nickel diets often recommend that individuals with SNAS should avoid cooking acidic foods in stainless steel cookware. Unfortunately, though well-intended, this advice is not entirely accurate. These recommendations are frequently based on conclusions drawn from poorly designed/poorly executed studies and not on well-conducted, relevant studies. Food contact materials, such as cookware and utensils, are subject to release limits for certain substances, including nickel, but it is important to follow the manufacturers’ instructions for care and cleaning (including pre-treatment before first use). If these recommendations are followed, stainless steel saucepans should not present a problem for individuals suffering from SNAS.(34)
While nickel release from nickel-containing food contact material into the foods are subject to nickel migration limits, a comparison of the ranges of values reported for nickel in fresh and canned foods revealed that these values can vary widely. Thus, it is not possible to determine, with any degree of certainty, whether a canning material, the canning process, and/or long-term storage in a can have a significant impact on the level of nickel in canned foods. Therefore, as a precautionary measure, it is recommended that individuals with SNAS consider the avoidance of canned food or consider canned foods to contain nickel in the medium to high values reported for each foodstuff category, especially as some studies(46)(47)(48)(49)(50)(51)(52)(53)(54)(55)(56)(57)(58)(59)(60)(61) have reported outliers that are significantly higher than the nickel content values reported by EFSA.(20)
According to the World Health Organization background document for development of World Health Organization Guidelines for Drinking Water Quality, Nickel in Drinking Water (2021)(62) consumers should flush chromium- or nickel-plated taps/faucets before using the water. Thus, the avoidance of tap water should not be necessary for individuals with SNAS if they follow this recommendation. The EFSA Update of the Risk Assessment of Nickel in Food and Drinking Water (2020)(20) indicates that the contribution to the mean dietary exposure to nickel from ‘bottled water’ is slightly higher than other types of water (e.g., tap water, ice, well water), but it does not raise a health concern. Therefore, the consumption of bottled water should not be a concern for individuals with SNAS.
Annex I to this fact sheet was designed as a guide for nickel-sensitized individuals that are susceptible to allergic reactions from oral exposure to nickel substances, using reliable sources in various regions (see footnotes to table and Reference section to the fact sheet for source details). The Annex I table provides an extensive, non-exhaustive list of foodstuffs that are categorized as high (red), medium (yellow), and low (green) in nickel. In order to assist users with compliance with a low nickel diet, each foodstuff within the relevant category is listed with its nickel content in terms of micrograms per serving (µg/serving), as well as micrograms per kilogram (µg/kg) of food. As a reminder, a low nickel diet should only be followed used if advised by and under the supervision of a dermatologist or other medical doctor with knowledge of nickel allergy.